How to screen false positives out of a change tile worklist

A paved rural road winding through farmland and low hills toward distant mountains under a cloudy sky.

A change tile worklist is only as good as the desk review that happens before someone gets in a truck. Run the raw output straight to field crews and you'll burn survey days on tiles where nothing actually changed: a cloud passed over, the soybeans came up, somebody pulled a tarp over a roof repair. None of that is new ground truth. All of it scores high enough to land on the list.

A screening pass that knows these patterns before the list goes out catches more of this than swapping imagery vendors ever will.

The usual suspects

Three patterns account for most of the noise on a change tile worklist.

Cloud shadow. A shadow moving across a tile between the basemap pass and the latest pass reads as a shift in reflectance almost identical to a cleared lot or a demolished structure. It usually shows up as a hard-edged dark patch running at an angle that doesn't line up with any built feature on the tile. If the edge of the "change" follows a diagonal with no relationship to a parcel line or road centerline, check the sun angle and acquisition time on both passes before trusting the score.

Seasonal vegetation. Crop emergence, leaf-off versus leaf-on, a wet spring greening up a pasture: all of these shift spectral response enough to trip a detector tuned for built change. These tiles tend to cluster by land cover class and by month. A tile that scores high every spring and every fall on the same quarter section is a seasonal signature, not a worklist item.

Construction tarps. A tarp over a roof, a staged material pile under plastic sheeting, a trailer parked on a lot: these read as sudden, high-contrast change against a stable basemap. Unlike cloud shadow, they don't follow a diagonal. Unlike seasonal vegetation, they don't repeat on a calendar. They show up once, hold for a few passes, and sometimes disappear again before a crew ever reaches the site.

Screening before dispatch

A desk reviewer should sort the change tile list before it reaches dispatch. A few checks catch most of the noise.

Pull two or three passes for any tile flagged with a high change score, so the comparison covers more than a single before-and-after pair. A true ground change, a new building pad, a widened road, a demolished structure, holds across subsequent passes. Cloud shadow and a stray tarp usually don't.

Check the shape of the flagged area against known geometry. Shadows and vegetation signatures rarely follow a straight edge that matches a parcel boundary, a building footprint, or a road centerline. Real construction does.

Group flags by land cover and season before trusting a cluster of high scores. If a batch lines up with a known crop calendar for that region, hold them and recheck after the flush passes instead of sending a crew into a field that's just growing.

The field check still happens. Screening decides which tiles earn one first.

A standing worklist that updates as new imagery comes in makes this screening faster than a one-time export does, because a reviewer can watch a tile's score across passes instead of judging it off a single snapshot. National Change Alerts builds that worklist from continuous high-resolution coverage, scoring each tile against the current basemap pass over pass, so a desk reviewer is working from a short list that already reflects more than one look at the ground.

What this doesn't fix

Screening narrows the list. It doesn't resolve the genuinely ambiguous cases: a tile sitting between "new structure" and "large shipping container," or a change that only shows up under one sun angle. Those still belong on the list for a human to look at, just not at the same priority as a flag with no persistence across passes, no match to known geometry, and a land-cover excuse sitting right there in the record.

If part of your resurvey cycle is still going to tiles that are really just shadow, crops, or a tarp, it's worth putting a continuously scored change tile index next to whatever list is reaching your desk now.

Get started

← Back to the blog